Patent Annuities and Portfolio Pruning: Renewal Fees, Lapse and Restoration under the Patents Act, 1970

Patent Portfolio Renewal Concept

Introduction : A patent is a reward for invention, but it is also a recurring expense. Only if the patentee pays a renewal fee periodically, then the patent stays in force. Also, the fee rises as the patent ages. For a business holding several patents, often in several countries, the annual bill becomes significant. Therefore, many firms respond by ‘pruning’ their portfolios. This blog sets out the legal provisions that govern that decision, analyses how a business may decide which patents to keep, discusses three judgments and closes with practical implications and suggestions for reform.

Legal Provisions

Term, Renewal and Cessation

A patent lasts twenty years from the date of filing. The first renewal fee falls due at the end of the second year. A fee is payable every year after that. The fee is graded. A company filing electronically pays ₹4,000 a year for the third to sixth years, rising in bands to ₹40,000 a year for the sixteenth to twentieth. On the other hand, natural persons, startups, small entities and educational institutions pay one-fifth of these amounts. Since 2024, a ten per cent reduction applies where fees for at least four years are paid in advance electronically.

If the fee is not paid, the patent ‘shall cease to have effect’ under Section 53(2). However, as per Rule 80(1A) it is subject to an extension of up to six months. Once it ceases, Section 53(4) provides that its subject matter ‘shall not be entitled to any protection’.

Restoration and Its Limits

Section 60 permits an application for restoration within eighteen months of cessation, but a verified statement explaining the failure to pay needs to be provided. It is contingent upon the satisfaction of the Controller that the failure was ‘unintentional’ and that there was no undue delay, and the application may be opposed. Even after restoration, Section 62 protects persons who began using the invention during the lapse. Also, it bars suits for infringement in that period.

Working, Surrender and Compulsory Licensing

Patentees must file a statement of working in Form 27. It has to done once every three financial years. Three years after grant, any person interested may seek a compulsory licence on the ground, among others, that the invention is not worked in India. In addition, under Section 63, a patentee may also surrender a patent, but only after publication and notice to persons with a registered interest.

Legal Analysis

Commercial Relevance and Licensing Prospects

The graded fee schedule reflects a policy choice: while low early fees allow inventors to test the market, the higher later fees encourage owners to release patents that no longer pay for themselves. For a business, the crucial question is whether a patent covers a product that is sold today or is planned for the near future. A patent on a line of discontinuation, or on a feature that competitors have designed around, offers little return on a ₹40,000 annual fee. More importantly, the cost multiplies when the invention is also protected abroad. Licensing prospects may change this, since a patent the owner does not use may still be valuable to another firm.

Blocking Value and the Working Requirement

A firm may keep a patent on an alternative technology only to stop rivals from using it as a workaround to compete with the firm. Indian law, however, does not treat a patent as a purely defensive right. Section 83(a) states that patents are granted to secure that inventions are ‘worked in India on a commercial scale.’ An unworked patent is exposed to a compulsory licence. On one view, this weakens the case for maintaining blocking patents. While other views hold that, the risk is limited because the applicant for a compulsory licence carries the initial burden of making out a prima facie case.

Abandoning a Product-Critical Patent

The most serious mistake in pruning would be to let a patent lapse when it protects a commercial product. A business that drops a patent as a deliberate cost-saving measure will struggle to show that the failure to pay was ‘unintentional.’ A successful restoration too would protect the competitors who entered during the under Section 62. A lapse may also breach a licence or financing agreement requiring the patent to be maintained. Unlike surrender, a lapse requires no notice to licensees, so surrender is the more transparent route where others rely on the patent.

Case Laws

Bry-Air Prokon SAGL v. Union of India (2022)

Patentee’s agent failed to pay renewal fees despite the instructions to reniew leading to lapse of patent. The Delhi High Court held that an agent’s negligence, without contributory negligence by the applicant, has been ‘liberally considered by the Courts.’ Since the consequences of a lapse are ‘very serious’, the court allowed the patentee to seek restoration. The instant case distinguishes an owner who intended to keep a patent from one who chose to let it go.

SPV Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Controller General of Patents and Designs (2024)

Restoration was refused because the patentee had not produced ‘concrete evidence’ of the family emergency that caused its attorney to miss the deadline. The Delhi High Court setting the order aside, noted that regular Form 27 filings and a timely restoration application showed ‘no intention to abandon the patent’ and described the default as ‘a procedural lapse’. A record of regular compliance can thus later serve as evidence of intent.

Bayer Corporation v. Union of India (2014)

A compulsory licence granted to Natco over Bayer’s patented drug. The compulsory license was upheld by the Bombay High Court holding that working in India does not always require local manufacture, but the patentee must explain why the invention is not manufactured here. Keeping a patent without adequate working therefore carries its own risk.

Practical Implications

Rather than deciding in a hurry whenever a fee falls due, a business is better served by reviewing its portfolio once a year. Each patent can be linked to the products it protects. It can then be judged on its commercial use, its licensing interest, its blocking value and the years it has left, and the review can be timed with the Form 27 cycle. No patent should be dropped without approval from the technical, commercial and legal teams. Any agreement that requires the patent to be maintained should be checked first. SPV Laboratories also shows why deadlines should not be left entirely to agents, since the Patent Office’s intimation in that case went to the patentee’s old agent. The 2024 advance payment discount does lower costs. Because it requires four years to be paid at once, though, larger firms are better placed to use it than startups.

Conclusion

Renewal fees encourage patentees to release inventions they no longer value. If done with care and caution, pruning is sensible and advantageous to the patentee. However, a deliberate lapse of patent is difficult to reverse. Section 62 restricts the benefit of restoration even when granted. Two reforms may be considered: first, requiring the Patent Office to notify the patentee directly, and not only the agent on record, before a patent ceases; and second, requiring notice to registered licensees before a lapse. Until then, an annual review remains the most reliable safeguard.

Author:- Apurva Damle, in case of any queries please contact/write back to us at support@ipandlegalfilings.com or   IP & Legal Filing.